The Journal of Veterinary Science reviews all the submitted manuscripts.
The editor selects peer referees upon the recommendation of the
Editorial Board members or from the specialist database owned by
the Editorial Board. The peer-reviewers will be blinded with respect
to the name and their affiliations of the author(s). Typically,
the scientific review of manuscript is handled by an Associate Editor
who selects two investigators in the field as referees according
to recommendation of Editor or Editorial board . If decided necessary,
review for statistics may be additionally requested.
Acceptance of the manuscript is decided, based on the critiques
and recommended decision of the referees. A referee's decision is
made as "acceptance without revision", "acceptance
after minor revision", "review again after revision",
and rejection". If there is marked discrepancy in the decisions
between two referees or in opinions between the author and referee(s),
The Editor may send the manuscript to another referee for additional
comments and recommended decision. Four repeated decisions of "review
again after revision" are regarded as "rejection".
The reviewed manuscript are returned back to the corresponding author
with comments and recommended revisions. Name and individual decisions
of the referees are not transmitted to the author.
The usual reasons of rejection are insufficient originality, serious
scientific flaws, poor quality of illustrations, improper manuscript
form or absence of massage that might be important to the intended
readers. Though the peer review process may in general take four
to eight weeks after submission of the manuscript, more time may
be need to finalize the review process.
Revisions are usually requested to take account of criticism and
comments made by referees. Two copies of revised manuscript should
be submitted, including one set of original illustrations. Failure
to resubmit the revised manuscript within eight weeks is regarded
as a withdrawal. Corresponding author must indicate clearly what
alterations have been made in response to the referees comments
point by point. Acceptable reasons should be given for noncompliance
with any recommendation of the referees.
Once accepted, original articles will be published without page
charges within six months.
|